Back
Home
NextBack
Home
NextHome
My Debates
$1800
FONZI ON SPECTER
BAD AMERICAN
MAYBE WE MISSED SOMETHING
RUBY NOT CONNECTED
VIEW JASON BURKE'S BIRTH
BACKYARD PHOTOS
too old to go to prison
DALLAS FBI AGENT ARRESTED
Operation 40
GARY REVEL
Lloyd Jowers deposition
COMMUNIST THREAT
OSWALD'S JESUIT SPEECH
EXTRA INFORMATION
NSAM's
BLOOMGARDEN   THE GUN
JOSEPH MILTEER
WELL DONE BY CHRIS DOLMAR
CIA AND THE MEDIA
RIFLE SHELLS ARE BOGUS
CIA STAR FOR OSWALD
SHADOWS AT 12:30
OSWALD IN CAROUSEL CLUB
RUBY ARRESTS
CONTROLLING THE MEDIA
audio clips
KLEIN's
EXPOSE'
ODIO-LIEBLER
WILLENS BOOK
THOSE PAINES AGAIN
WHICH SHOT IS EASIER
ROSCOE WHITE
Testimony
RFK ASSASSINATION
OSWALD'S MILITANT NEWSPAPER
PHOTO OF ASSASSIN
WHO'S WHO ON COMMISSION
KENNEDY HATER
HSCA MEDICAL TESTIMONY
Assassination X Rays and Photos
FROM DPD WEBSITE
MICHAEL T. GRIFFITH
THE POLLS
BUTCH's  PAGE
DELAYED REVIEW INFORMATION
ALWAYS ABOUT MONEY FOLKS
EXECUTIVE ORDERS
jfk jr
what kind of country
CASE OPEN
OSAMA BIN LADEN VS. FBI
MUST SEE VIDEOS
HER FATHER'S  VOICE
VOLUMES PAGES
SOME CLIPS FROM YOUTUBE
TIPPIT SHOOTING
HOWARD WILLENS
3126 HARLENDALE
REASON FOR TEXAS TRIP
WALKER SHOOTING
no prints on the rifle
SAM KINNEY
CASE DISMISSED
DR. PERRYS PRESS CONFERENCE
BAY OF PIGS AND IKE
OSWALD AND RUBY
GEORGE DEMORENDSCHILDT
witness list from dpd
THE MAGIC BULLET
DALLAS DETECTIVES
DANIEL PATRICK MOYNIHAN
MARINA TO ARRB
COLATERAL DMAGE
BUSH AND THE S AND L SCANDAL
READNG BILL COSBY
GUY BANNISTER
CIA AND BAY OF PIGS
SENATOR SCHWEIKER
BETHESDA
DAVID ATLEE PHILLIPS
LORAN EUGENE HALL (CIA)
KEN AND DAVE
oswald connected to anticastro group
SAFE HOUSE
DALLAS DETECTIVES REPORTS
DENNIS DAVID
LEFT-RIGHT--RIGHT-LEFT
ROY TRULY
JAMES ANGLETON
THE RETURN TRIP TO D. C.
oswald WAS never arraigned
ANN GOODPASTURE
texas theater show times
OSWALD'S HEIGHTSS
LINNIE MAE RANDALL II
JAMES TAGUE
lousy witness bad memory
GERRY PATRICK HEMMING
Z FILM
HEAR NO EVIL
RIFLE REBARRALLED
BERNARD WEISSMAN
HSCA IMMUNITY
FRANK MOTE
CIA LIES TO EVERYONE
DALLAS POLICE RADIOS
CIA  MURPHY
A TOUCH OF HUMOR
THE FBI TELEX
MAUSER RFEPORTS
SYNOPSIS
WALTER REED HOSPITAL
VOODOO OF WCR SUPPORTERS
MICHAEL PAINE - OSWALD
IMPEERSONATING OSWALD
OSWALD AND THE CIA
CASTRO ASSSSINATION
RUTH PAINE
FBI ADVANCE WARNING
BILL O'REILLY II
JFK-RFK CONNECTION
FIRE DARTS THROUGH UMBRELLA
DOCTORS PERRY AND CLARK
CUBANS HATED JFK
AUTOPSY INFO
marina and demorendschildt photo
SORRELS- LAPEL PINS
JANE ROMAN
CIA WEAPONS
CIA-NOSENKO DEFECTION
CITATIONS
HELMS TO CHURCH COMMITTEE
Hickey lawsuit
TWO SIDES
OSWALD's DEFECTION
DICK RUSSELL VS. LBJ
MEXICO CITTY
DEPORT MARINA
ORDERING-RECEIVING THE WEAPONS
POPOURRI
magic bullet
CIA KILLED JFK
JFK ADVERSARIES
JACK RUBY
WHO MOVED THE BOXES   Givens VI
HSCA Medical Interviews
PUT UP - shut up
brown and root, haliburtin
THE NEW DALLAS
CURTAIN RODS
RACE TO GRASSY KNOLL
Chapter 4c
TOM ALYEA FILM
free online book
FIXING THE U. S. A.
TODAY
THE ENEMY WITHIN
HUNG JURY IN DALLAS
CANNOT DUPLICATE SHOTS
ARRIVAL AT BETHESDA
Spy Stuff
DENIED LEGAL ASSISTANCE
BAY OF PIGS SECRETS  - C IA
FINDING THE RIFLE
PARAFFIN TEST
OIL DEPLETION ALLOWANCE
Single Bullet THEORY
FIREARMS LAWS   JERRY McCLEER
Lho-ferrie-marcello
MEXICO CITY
PRESSURE DR. PERRY
Frederic Whitehurst
TRAMP PHOT5OS
WARREN REPORT REJECTED
KATZENBACH MEMO
DROP LBJ IN 1964
JFK PORTRAIT
OSWALD-ODIO
DEALY PLAZA (ARIEL VIEW)
GENESIS 1.1
DALLAS POLICE WEBSITE
JOHN CONNALLY BIO
HSCA VOLUME XI
CUBAN EXHILES-CIA
EXHUMING OSWALD's BODY
CRITICAL THINKING
T F BOWLEY
FEDERAL RESERVE BANK
GEORGE BUSH
KILLING CITIZENS
SECRET HISTORY OF THE U. S. A.
DETENTE WITH CUBA
MULTIPLE OSWALDS
HOOVER VS. HENRY WADE
CIA AND THE MEDIA
FOREIGN OR DOMESTIC
MARINA O N OPRAH WINFREY
NIXON AID SAYS LBJ DID IT
IN A NUTSHELL
ZAPATA OIL
LEFT-  RIGHT HANDED
STRANGE FBI DEATHS
1976 SWINE FLU
LAWRENCE W CUSAK
Hint of conspiracy
July 26-nov 22
JEAN DANIEL
GRASSY KNOLL PROVEN.htm
WHO KILLED RFK
KATHLEEN KENNEDY TOWNSEND
COST OF MEXICO TRIP
DELAY OSWALD'S TRANSFER
bullet from knoll
Weitzman-Labruda
RICHARD M. BISSELL
KLEIN, SCIBOR,WALDMAN,MICHAELIS
BOUNCE MIchael BADEN
CIA SAYS HUNT WAS IN DALLAS
DRIVERS LICENSE
ELIMINATE DISSEDENTS
DICTABELT UPDATE
EVILS OF NATIONAL SECURITY
DOROTHY HUNT'S DEATH
CITY OF HATE
McADAMS LOSES..."AGAIN"
TOO MANY BRAINS
JFK VS NSA
EARL WARREN
ONI-OFFICE OF NAVEL INTEKLLIGENCE
FAKE RIFLE ORDER
second killing of jfk
JACK RUBY
Halliburton Questioned on $1
OSWALD REFUSED LEGAL COUNSEL
TRUTH - JUSTICE
anna k. nelson   (ARRB)
FOREIGN OR DOMESTIC
THAT DAMNED CIA AGAIN
RICHARD HELMS PERJURY
WILLIAM COLBY
I WONDER WHAT PART THIS GEM PLAY
HOWARD BRENNAN
SALUTE TO VINCE PALAMARA
WARREN REPORT REJECTED
A MATTER OF TIMING
A MISSING CAMERA
cia lied to rfk
VIETNAM COUP
DAVID REITZES
PUNISH FBI AGENTS
SUSPECT COMPOSITE PHOTO
CIA SUPPLIED OSWALD LITERATURE
RATING JFK
MORE McADAMS
MISSING EMPLOYEES
DON'T WORRY 'BOUT THE COMMIES
COERSION
LIST OF PEOPLE FRAMED AND OVERTURNED
HSCA
RICHARD M. BISSELL
MORE INFORMANTS STILL OUT THERE
JFK ASSASSINATION POLLS
OSWALD, BANNISTER FERRIE
RICHARD CASE NAGELL
MARGUERITE OSWALD
WEST COAST JFK CONFERENCE
KANGAROO COURT
DPD DISPATCHER REMOVED
LEE HARVEY OSWALD
criminal aliases II
priscilla johnson mCmillian
HOWARD BRENNAN-IMMUNITY
NEVER DEBATE EVIDENCE-TESTIMONY
FBI JURISDICTION
LETS I D SOME CIA FOLKS
SECRET SERVICE TOLLS
THE DIFFERANCES
FOUND THIS ON THE INTRNET TODAY
MULTIPLE SERIAL NUMBERS
SOUNDS PRETTY SMART TO ME
JAMES FILES PHONY
A CALL FROM JFK Jr.
WANT TO KNOW INFO
CIA, MEDIA, STURGIS
DOUG HORNE
JOE O'DONNELL
truman and the cia
NO TUMBLING BULLET
CHARACTER ASSASSINATION
CIA AND THE MOB
GEORGE AND THE CIA
POSSIBLE DIVERSION
ISSUES MISSED
SNIPERS SMOKERS NOOK
the differences
richard helms
SALUTE TO GIL JESUS
cleaned and pressed
ANTON BATEY
some w c exhibits
DOROTHY HUNT
GERALD RUDOLPH FORD
JFK AND THE DIFFERENTIALS
RICHARD HELMS-CIA
SBT BORN ON -3-13-64
preparing the body after the aut
scavengers
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
STAY AWAY FROM RUTH PAINE
MORE WARREN BULLSHIT
civil rights violated
seymour hersh
CONNECTIONS
DISASSEMBLING THE MC RIFLE
JFK BOOKS FOR SALE
MLK  CONSPIRACY PROVEN IN COURT
BAY OF PIGS.HTML
E howard hunt - frank sturgis
THAT MC 6.5 AMMO AGAIN
FEDERAL RESERVE BANK
Z-FILM ALTERED
KENNEDY VS. CIA
S S BELIEVED IN CONSPIRACY
CHANGING DEALY PLAZA
scorecard
CHAIN OF CUSTODY
cover-up
PAYING THE PIPER
GENERAL WALKER BIO
SOME VOLUME PAGES
HOOVER LBJ PHONE CALL
FBI SCREWED UP BADLY
FREE PRESS MY ASS
oswsald learning russian
ALYEA REPLIES TO TOMNLN
GEORGE JOANNIDES
FEDERAL TAX DOLLARS
curry's book very valuable
MORE NASTY STUFF
lt. martello
GERRY FORD THE RAT
FROM DPD WEBSITE
GEORGE BUSH GUILTY
cia assassination files
STAY OFF OF LIMO
GERALD RUDOLPH FORD
A LITTLE GIRL'S MEMORIES
JFK and the Unspeakable
ANOTHER INCOMPLETE ISSUE
OFFICER M. l. BAKER
MOTORCADE OCCUPANTS
ORIGIN OF SHOTS
WORTHWHILE QUOTES
ANOTHER SHELL GAME
timmy brennan
BEHIND CLOSED DOORS
WALKER PHOTO HOLE
LEE HARVEY OSWALD
D B THOMAS REPORT
FUNERAL REHEARSAL
LIMO STOPPED
RADIO DEBATE
STEVEN LOUIE WITT PHONY
POI
HOW TO FIX IT
LEMAY WAS AT AUTOPSY
JFK VS U. S. STEEL
MISSION STATEMENT
WHAT THE HELL IS THIS?
ADVICE COLUMN
WESTERN UNION
THE RALEIGH CALL
RICHARD STOLLEY
LIGHTS OUT
NO RIFLE PRACTICE
REGIS BLAHUT
CHRISTOPHER DODD
RECORDS WITHHELD
BILDERBERGS
MALCOLM WALLACE
ALTGENS
SECRET SERVICE DRINKING
JOHN CARO
DISINFORMATION
I G REPORT
FIRST DICK SPRAGUE
AUDREY BELL II
ROBERT BLAKELY
ROBERT OSWALD
AUDIO PAGE
JACK RUBY
some slides
CASE OPEN
MLK CONSPIRACY
HSCA Volume VII     MISSING SLIDES
500.shtml
HOSTY NOTE FROM OSWALD
INTERNATIONAL CONSPIRACY
ZAPRUDER fILM
SOLVED INSTANTLY
EXTRA JFK  BOOKS FOR SALE
GUESS WHO WROTE
VIDEO PAGE
Harold Weisberg
THE AUTOPSY
CHRISTCHURCH STAR
BETHESDA
B O H
THE ARREST
alter testimony
ALTERING EVIDENCE
AUDREY BELL
INVITATION
ALL BULLETS
Altgens Photo
KAY SPENCER
B Y PHOTOS
CIA COERCION
photos
VEITNAM
FRICK n FRACK
CIA CONNECTIONS
YOU ASKED FOR IT
FAKE SECRET SERVICE AGENTS
FALSE DEFECTORS
DALLAS SPEECH
DAMAGE CONTROL
CROOKED FBI AGENT
CROFT PHOTO WITH ANAYLISIS
DALE MYERS
DALLAS PD DICTABELT
ANY COMMENTS
HENRY WADE
MEDIA PAGE
SOME WEISBERG PAGES
TRUMAN AND THE CIA
WASH OUT THE LIMO
ORIGINAL SUSPECTS
SLING MOUNTS
ONLY 2 SHELLS FOUND
ORDERS OF SILENCE
A QUESTION OF CHARACTER
11 O
JFK SCORECARD
JFK vs CIA
Dan Rather
MARK LANE vs BUGLOISI
JOHN LATTIMER
LAW SUITS
YOUR TAX DOLLARS AT WORK
BUGLOISI
THE DIFFERANCE
WHAT differences
UNITED FRUIT
STRANGE CONNECTIONS
U
Who can I D these rifles
POOR TIMMY
WIKILEAKS
NEEDS COMMENT
PERJURY
RUNNERS
NEEDS EXPLANATION
Regis BLAHUT
WHY WE FIGHT
WELL
Jack Ruby
LEE J BOWERS
SECRET TESTIMONY
WALLY WORLD
doug horne
Rather Lies
GIL JESUS PAGE
Great letter sent to Prof
jfk speech
Tink Thompson
OLIVER STONE
FBI
Lee Harvey Oswald
marina
Reasonable Doubt
RECLAIMING HISTORY
EXECUTIVE ORDERS
NORTHWOODS
Rewards
Characters
AMERICA
G. H. W.  BUSH
HELSINKI
here are withheld doc's that we know of
HORNE  REPORT
CTKA
Critics
NOT INVESTIGATED
LOPEZ REPORTBack
Home
NextBack
Home
NextHome
PARAFFIN TESTS

PARAFFIN TEST

Pat Speer has written an interesting article on Bugliosi's
(mis)handling of the paraffin evidence.

Speer says that Bugliosi neglected the testimony of FBI agent John
Gallagher who told the Warren Commission that Oswald's cheek casts
tested negative by Neutron Acitvation Analysis, suggesting Oswald had
not shot a rifle.

But Speer's piece speaks for itself.

Iv'e pasted it below and it's also available on-line at:
http://www.reclaiminghistory.org


Gary

lJuly 24, 2007
Bugliosi Fails the Paraffin Test
by Pat Speer

On Page 964 of Reclaiming History, as part of his list of evidence
proving Lee Harvey Oswald killed President Kennedy, Vincent Bugliosi
states:

"Dallas Police performed a paraffin test on Oswald's hands at the time
of his interrogation to determine if he had recently fired a revolver,
and the results were positive, indicating the presence of nitrates
from gunpowder residue on his hands."

This statement is incredibly deceptive.  By including this statement
in his list, Bugliosi is clearly suggesting that this evidence is
indicative of Oswald's guilt, even though he readily admits 800 pages
earlier that "the paraffin test is not conclusive...mere handling of a
weapon may leave nitrates of the skin, even without firing it." (p.
164)  Even worse, when one looks at the results of another test,
performed on the paraffin casts of Oswald's cheek, one can only
conclude they suggest that Oswald did not fire the shots that killed
Kennedy.  You see, while the tests of Oswald's hands were positive,
the tests for Oswald's cheek were negative.  This suggests that he did
not fire a rifle on November 22, 1963.

Bugliosi tries to tackle this problem. In a footnote on page 165,
Bugliosi states "Predictably, the paraffin cast for Oswald's right
cheek showed no reaction." Predictably? He explains by asserting that
there is no gap through which residue from a rifle could leak onto the
cheek.  He then cites the Warren Commission testimony of FBI Special
Agent Cortlandt Cunningham to support this supposition. On page 79 of
his endnotes (available on a separate cd-rom) he acknowledges that
former FBI agent William Turner reported that he'd spoken to Dr.
Vincent Guinn about tests performed by Guinn, and that Guinn had found
nitrates in abundance on casts of the cheeks of men who'd fired rifles
like the one owned by Oswald. Bugliosi dismisses Turner's assertion,
however, essentially calling him a liar, by stating "There is simply
no way to square this with the testimony and experience of the Dallas
Police and FBI."  Bugliosi then explains that two Dallas Police
officers testified that they didn't think a test of the cheek would
read positive for a man firing a rifle, and that Cunningham testified
that an FBI agent had fired the rifle three times but that tests for
his cheek had come up negative. Bugliosi begs of his readers "Why in
the world would these two Dallas officers lie under oath about
something like this?" and that "No one could really believe this is
perjured testimony, if for no other reason that no professional would
lie under oath on a matter that he knows other experts could easily
refute him on." (endnotes, p. 80)

But what Bugliosi misses, or simply chooses to ignore, is that these
men were discussing the standard paraffin test performed in the
1960's, and that Turner asked Guinn about a different test entirely
involving neutron activation analysis of the paraffin casts.
Bugliosi, who elsewhere cites conversations with Guinn, never mentions
discussing this with Guinn himself, nor of Guinn denying that he'd
conducted such tests.  He never mentions that, as exposed in Professor
Gerald McKnight's Breach of Trust, Guinn called the FBI in 1964
suggesting they conduct these tests (McKnight, Breach of Trust, p.211)
and that, per the testimony of the FBI's John Gallagher-the last
testimony taken by the Warren Commission-the FBI had indeed conducted
neutron activation analysis on the paraffin cast of Oswald's cheek.

It seems more than a coincidence that Bugliosi keeps the results of
this test from his readers Gallagher testified that there was more
gunshot residue on the outside of the paraffin cast than on the side
exposed to Oswald's cheek and that he could therefore reach no
conclusion as to whether Oswald had fired a rifle. He stated
furthermore that "I found that there was more barium and antimony on
the inside surface of the cast than you would find on the cheek of an
individual who had recently washed his cheek" without explaining why
anyone should assume Oswald had just washed his cheek. (While the
casts had reportedly been washed, nothing was offered to substantiate
that rinsing a wax cast would have nearly the effect on the levels of
residue as Oswald's washing his face.) (15WH751)

This unexpected result, which suggests that the gunshot residue levels
were too low to conclude Oswald had recently fired a rifle, becomes
even more intriguing when one considers that researcher Harold
Weisberg, through a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit, received the
controls for this test and found that gunshot residue was always
present on the cheeks of those firing a rifle like Oswald's (Weisberg,
Post Mortem, p. 437).  These controls, moreover, confirmed what Guinn
had told the FBI in his phone call, (the FBI document describing this
phone call is listed in McKnight's book as R.M Jevons to Conrad
2/27/64 memo), what Guinn told an August 1964 conference (Lane, Rush
to Judgment, p. 153), what Guinn published in an October 1964 article
in the Journal of the Forensic Science Society (p. 189), and what
Guinn later told Turner (Turner, Invisible Witness, p. 76).

Also of significance is that, unlike the paraffin tests originally
performed on Oswald, the Neutron Activation Analysis performed by
Gallagher only gained in respectability in the years following the
assassination (Scientific Evidence in Criminal Cases, 1986, p.255),
and is considered to be a reliable indicator of whether a suspect has
fired a rifle.  Larry Ragle, a retired Director of Forensic Sciences
for Santa Ana, California, in his 1995 book Crime Scene, explains: "By
design, revolvers can leak...Rifles, depending on their construction and
wear, can also leak.  There is only one way to determine the leakage
capacity of any weapon and that is to collect samples from the hands
or face firing the weapon under controlled conditions while using the
corresponding ammunition." (Ragle, Crime Scene, p. 172) Of course,
this is precisely the kind of test performed by Guinn and Gallagher in
1964.

In sum, the gunshot residue tests conducted by Guinn and Gallagher
create real doubt that Oswald fired the rifle found in the Book
Depository.  Rather than acknowledge this, Bugliosi dismisses these
tests as a William Turner pipe dream.  That he is outraged that anyone
might think FBI agent Cortlandt Cunningham a liar, while
simultaneously implying that William Turner-a man who left the FBI
after he'd had enough of J. Edgar Hoover's misuse of the agency-is a
liar, is outrageous. Perhaps Bugliosi's blind hatred of all
suggestions of Oswald's innocence has blinded his thinking. In any
event, his research simply can not be trusted.

For more information on the paraffin tests and their significance, see
chapter 4 at www.patspeer.com.



From page 560 of the WCR  below

 

The paraffin test on Oswald's hands were Positive.

Nitrates can be obtained from any number of sources.

i.e, Paper, Wood, Cardboard Paint & Urine to name a few.

The problem with the positive nitrates on Oswald's hands is that most nitrates were on the "Palm Side"

When obtaining nitrates from a weapon, the nitrates are on the back side of the hand due to the palm side being ON the weapon.

Paraffin tests of Oswald's hands are below from the Dallas Police website.

http://jfk.ci.dallas.tx.us/

 

 

 

Notice that the nitrates are on the Palm side of Oswald's hands.

When firing a weapon the nitrates are on the Back side of the hand because the Palm side is covered by the weapon.

 

Nitrates are caused by several other sources such as, Paper, Cardboard, wood, Paint & Urine.

Oswald's job was to handle Cardboard boxes of paper books on the 6th floor which was getting a New floor laid on 11/22/63.


FROM BEN HOLMES NEWSGROUPS

 

12. "Tests were also made with a nuclear reactor on the cast of Oswald's cheek
Dr. Vincent P. Guinn, head of the activation analysis program of the general
atomic division of General Dynamics Corporation, made an analysis of the
paraffin cast, the results of which were presented to the Commission. Dr. Guinn
said that he hand his colleagues reasoned 'that if a gun was fired and some of
the powder came back on the hands and cheek, some of the bullet primer should
also come back'.  They decided to try looking for elements by putting the wax
impressions of hands and cheeks into a nuclear reactor.'  Guinn said the had
informed the FBI that it would be worth-while to utilize 'activation analysis'
because the Dallas police had merely used the chemical paraffin test.

'We bought a similar rifle from the same shop as Oswald and conducted two
parallel tests,' Guinn said.  'One person fired the rifle on eight occasions.'
The scientist stated that paraffin casts were made and when tested by means of
radioactivity, 'it was positive in all eight cases and showed a primer on both
hands and both cheeks. [Weisberg, who has seen Guinn's report, quotes "heavy
deposits" on the cheek casts] Then we took the casts of Oswald's cheek and put
them in a nuclear reactor.'  Guinn added, 'I cannot say what we found out about
Oswald because it is secret until the publication of the Warren Commission
Report." - Mark Lane's Rush to Judgment, pg 152-153

These comparative tests, which were done by a recognized expert - were
contradicted by Cunningham's testimony on pg 561 of the WCR (despite the fact
that Cunningham had *NO* experience with NAA) - but the Warren Commission was
not honest enough to present Guinn's evidence... This evidence is *exculpatory*
for Oswald...

Why was the WC dishonest enough to present Cunningham's testimony, without
allowing readers to know about Guinn's testing results?

Why were those test results of firing a rifle at Oak Ridge buried, and are still
denied by most LNT'ers today?


--

 

 

 

  Contact Information  tomnln@cox.net

Hit Counter